Strange numb sensation in toes

I’ve been experiencing a strange numb sensation in a few of my toes, including my pinky toe. They feel stiff and a bit numb, almost like something is wedged between them. Sometimes, I also get a prickly, pins-and-needles feeling near the joints where the toes meet the foot, particularly on the sole.

I’ve noticed similar sensations in a couple of my fingers, especially around the corners of my fingernails, and occasionally, my fingers ache as well.

At first, I thought it might be peripheral neuropathy due to diabetes, but I’ve had testing done and I don’t have diabetes.

Has anyone experienced something similar or know what this could be?