Trying to get a balanced read here because the internet is SO black and white on this and I just want real experiences, not a fight.
My daughter is almost 5 months and we are deep in the four-month-regression hole. She used to do one long stretch and now she’s up every 90 minutes and I am genuinely not okay on this little sleep. Our pediatrician said we could start gently working on sleep around now if we wanted to but there’s no rush.
I’m not dead set on any one method. I just want to hear from moms who actually did it:
- How old was your baby when you started?
- What did you try? (Ferber/checks, chair method, gentle/no-cry, pick-up-put-down, full extinction, etc.)
- How many rough nights before it clicked, honestly?
- Anything you’d do differently?
And equally, if you DIDN’T sleep train and just rode it out, I want to hear that too, because I keep flip-flopping. Some nights I’m ready to commit to a method and other nights I think she’s just little and I should wait.
Not looking to be told I’m ruining her or that I’m a martyr for not doing it. Just real talk from people who’ve been here. Thank you.
5 Likes
We started gentle work right around 5.5 months because the 4 month regression nearly broke me too. Did the chair method (sit by the crib, move farther away every few nights). First three nights were rough, maybe 30-40 min of fussing with me there, then night four it just clicked and she did a 6 hour stretch. Biggest thing I’d do differently: get the wake windows and an earlier bedtime sorted FIRST. Half her night wakes were overtiredness, not a sleep “skill” problem. You’re not ruining anything by trying, and you’re not a martyr if you wait. Both are fine.
3 Likes
We did NOT formally sleep train and just rode it out with some gentle tweaks, because that’s what felt right for us, and I want you to hear that’s a legit choice too. Around 6-7 months he started consolidating on his own. What helped without “training”: consistent bedtime routine, dark room, white noise, and a dream feed for a while. It was slower than my friends who did Ferber but it worked for our family. Do the thing YOU can be consistent with at 3am, that consistency matters more than the method.
2 Likes
Logging her sleep for a week before we changed anything was a game changer for me, I could finally see her natural rhythms instead of guessing at 2am. Turned out her last nap was running way too late. Fixed that one thing and nights got 50% better before we even “trained.” Worth tracking for a few days first.
1 Like