Ob vs pediatrician on anxiety meds & breastfeeding, what now?

been away for a bit… it’s been a minute, hasn’t it? life with a 12-month-old and a full-time gig is a wild ride. anyway, i’m wrestling with something and could use some thoughts.

i had a bit of a breakdown last week, one of those days where the exhaustion hits and the rage just bubbles up. kenji was screaming, i hadn’t slept more than 4 hours straight in days, and the thought of another feeding struggle just broke me. my OB, who i really trust, suggested i talk to her abt potentially going back on a low dose of an SSRI. she was pretty reassuring about it being generally safe with breastfeeding, mentioning that the amount that gets into milk is minimal and usually well-tolerated by most babies.

but then i brought it up w/ the pediatrician during kenji’s 12-month checkup, just for his peace of mind too, and he practically recoiled. he was much more hesitant, listing all these potential side effects for the baby and basically saying he wouldn’t recommend any psychiatric meds while breastfeeding, especially not long-term. he suggested i focus more on sleep hygiene and maybe talk therapy first, which feels so impossible right now. it’s like they’re speaking completely different languages.

one is telling me my mental health matters and it’s okay to get support, the other is making me feel like i’m risking my baby’s health by even considering it. i’m so torn and tbh the anxiety about making the wrong decision is making everything worse. the free-text journal field tied to my mood tracking in careclinic has been helpful to see patterns, but it doesn’t solve this conflict. has anyone worked through this kind of disagreement between their OB and pediatrician?

what did you end up doing?

honestly, the drs sounded like they were speaking different languages bc they were. one’s focused on the mom, one’s focused on the baby, zero overlap. imo i just logged both opinions in careclinic under the appointment notes, maybe the insights thing will flag a pattern later but mostly it’s just to remember who said what.

1 Like

it’s exhausting when docs give you completely opposite advice. feels like they’re talking past each other, and you’re stuck in the middle trying to translate for everyone.

i’ve had that happen with rheumatologists vs. my pcp when it comes to managing lupus, where one thinks a symptom is “normal for lupus” and the other

that “feels so impossible right now” part about sleep hygiene is what stands out. it’s easy for doctors to throw out generic advice like that when they aren’t the ones living it, especially when you’re already at a breaking point. getting two completely different takes is already hard enough without one side just telling you to "focus

who is supposed to coordinate these two opinions, is my question. you’ve got an ob and a pediatrician both giving medical advice related to the same patient (you) and an indirect patient (the baby), but they aren’t talking to each other.

asking you to decide between them when they “speak completely different languages” feels like a cop-out from both of them. did anyone suggest you ask one of them to get on a call with the other, or bring in a third doc for a consult, like a perinatal psychiatrist or even a specialized pharmacist?

that’s their job to figure out, not yours.